One thing I was sorely disappointed with is the lack of blockbuster action, specifically the fire-ice battle between Peter and Sylar. Mohinder was struggling so hard to hold back the door, and the explosions and the loud thunderings indicate a fierce amazing battle, and yet all we see is, well, Mohinder struggling to hold back the door. I understand there's a budget, but come on, some cool CGI would make all the difference. Granted, it wouldn't do anything to the storyline, but isn't action what viewers want? I know I would love the scene.

I've read a couple of reviews. Most loved it. Others claimed it was out of character and sloppy. I belonged to the majority. Loved it. Of course it was out of character. A major tragedy had happened, and five years had gone. People change. I think it was pretty well-done, given their 45 minute limit, having to explain the past 5 years. I have tons of questions for this AU, but with any luck, this is the last of this strange reality.

In conclusion, a very awesome, cool, dark What-If episode. Mid-season, I couldn't proclaim myself a big fan of Heroes, but with the recent excellent quality of the show, I'm now a big fan. Can't wait for the explosive (pun!) season finale.